
WelÂcome to Medieval Mixed-GenÂder Fight Club.
The first rule of Medieval Mixed-GenÂder Fight Club is: you do not talk about Medieval Mixed-GenÂder Fight Club.
The secÂond rule of Medieval Mixed-GenÂder Fight Club is: you DO NOT talk about Medieval Mixed-GenÂder Fight Club!
Why?
The PubÂlic Domain Review’s manÂagÂing ediÂtor, Hunter Dukes, wiseÂly argues that it’s because we have so litÂtle to go on, beyond these starÂtling images of “judiÂcial duels” between men and women in GerÂman fencÂing masÂter Hans TalÂhofÂfer’s illusÂtratÂed 15th-cenÂtuÂry “fight books.”
The male comÂbatÂant, armed with a woodÂen mace, starts out in a waist-deep hole.
The female, armed with a rock wrapped in a length of cloth, stands above, feet plantÂed to the ground.
Their matchÂing uniÂsex garÂments wouldn’t look out of place at the Met Gala, and proÂvide for maxÂiÂmum moveÂment as eviÂdenced by the acroÂbatÂic, and seriÂousÂly painful-lookÂing paces TalÂhofÂfer puts them through.



Dukes is not alone in wonÂderÂing what’s going on here, and he doesn’t mince words when callÂing bullÂshit on those responÂsiÂble for “hastiÂly researched artiÂcles” eagerÂly proÂnouncÂing them to be action shots of divorce-by-comÂbat.
Such bruÂtal methÂods of forÂmal uncouÂpling had been renÂdered obsoÂlete cenÂturies before TalÂhofÂfer began work on his instrucÂtionÂal manÂuÂals.
In a 1985 artiÂcle in Source: Notes in the HisÂtoÂry of Art, AlliÂson CoudÂert, a proÂfesÂsor of ReliÂgious StudÂies at UC Davis, posits that TalÂhofÂfer might have been drawÂing on the past in these pages:
I would sugÂgest that no records of judiÂcial duels between husÂbands and wives exists after 1200 because of both changes in the realÂiÂty and the ideÂal of what a woman could be and do. Before 1200, women may well have batÂtled their husÂbands. Women underÂstood and defendÂed the imporÂtance of their ecoÂnomÂic and adminÂisÂtraÂtive roles in the houseÂhold. After the twelfth cenÂtuÂry, howÂevÂer, law, cusÂtom and reliÂgion made marÂiÂtal duels all but unthinkÂable.
Why would TalÂhofÂfer bothÂer includÂing archaÂic mateÂrÂiÂal if the focus of his FechtÂbuchs was givÂing less expeÂriÂenced fightÂers conÂcrete inforÂmaÂtion for their betÂterÂment?
We like the notion that he might have been seekÂing to inject his manÂuÂscripts with a bit of an erotÂic charge, but conÂcede that scholÂars like CoudÂert, who have PhDs, research chops, and actuÂal experÂtise in the subÂject, are probÂaÂbly warmer when reckÂonÂing that he was just covÂerÂing his hisÂtorÂiÂcal bases.
For now, let us enjoy these images as art, and posÂsiÂble sources of inspiÂraÂtion for avant-garde cirÂcus acts, HalÂloween couÂples cosÂtumes, and ValenÂtines.


Explore more images from the 15th-cenÂtuÂry FechtÂbuchs of Hans TalÂhofÂfer here and here.
via the PubÂlic Domain Review
RelatÂed ConÂtent
What It’s Like to ActuÂalÂly Fight in Medieval Armor
How to Get Dressed & Fight in 14th CenÂtuÂry Armor: A ReenÂactÂment
The Medieval MasÂterÂpiece, the Book of Kells, Is Now DigÂiÂtized & Put Online
- Ayun HalÂlÂiÂday is the Chief PriÂmaÂtolÂoÂgist of the East VilÂlage Inky zine and author, most recentÂly, of CreÂative, Not Famous: The Small PotaÂto ManÂiÂfesto and CreÂative, Not Famous ActivÂiÂty Book. FolÂlow her @AyunHalliday.




