While it seems that a large section of the internet has found Obama's "we're all New Yorkers today" line awww-worthy and endearing, I found it rather offensive. The strange thing about this tragedy is that it seems that everyone wants to "be a part of it" sharing their stories of how they were sitting comfortably on their couch or at their school desk thousands of miles away watching a television screen, and how devestated they were. Everyone wants to "be a part of it"... except for those people who actually had to live through the experience. Because no one who actually lost loved ones, or breathed in the ashes, or smelled the fumes of jet fuel actually wants to have had those experiences. People line up to claim a right to the hurt and anguish of the day, even though they never had to live any of the actual horror. It's sort of like a group of people talking about the hurt and pain of racism, and some white girl saying that she "totally understands" because she has to deal with sexism... No, it's not the same thing. And to try to claim a piece of the tragedy, as though you're entitled to it as an American is wrong. I wasn't here at the time. It wasn't my tragedy, but iit is my home now, and my friends and neighbors and co-workers were here. And it really upsets me how everyone wants to "be a part of it". It was an awful fucking event, and if you lived in the midwest your whole life and have no connections to anyone involved--NO.
When someone says "remember" it doesn't mean that you should navel-gaze and make it all about you, you, you.
For me, remembering September 11th means honoring and remembering those people who died for their country, even though they may never have enlisted. The people who died in the World Trade Center Towers and the airplanes never signed up to die for their country--but they did. They died because decades of messed up foreign policy at the hands of government and military leaders had left a group of people overseas full of fear and hatred for our country. They died because they were "American," whether they actually supported the decisions of those in power or not.
For me, September 11th is about the loss of innocents; it's about the first responders who rushed in to save lives; it's about my friends and neighbors who still suffer anxiety, respiratory illnesses, and other diseases from the fall-out; it's about the people of Chinatown who were largely ignored, even though they were the largest residential neighborhood adjacent to the attack site, even though their local economy was essentially shut down for months, because they're mainly immigrants and poorer people and many didn't speak English; it's about people on airplanes who must have known they were going to die but refused to let others become targets as well...
And it's about remembering that fear and hatred are what caused this tragedy in the first place. Lest we forget and become so consumed of fear and hatred that we become no better than the enemy our leaders claim to be fighting.
When someone says "remember" it doesn't mean that you should navel-gaze and make it all about you, you, you.
For me, remembering September 11th means honoring and remembering those people who died for their country, even though they may never have enlisted. The people who died in the World Trade Center Towers and the airplanes never signed up to die for their country--but they did. They died because decades of messed up foreign policy at the hands of government and military leaders had left a group of people overseas full of fear and hatred for our country. They died because they were "American," whether they actually supported the decisions of those in power or not.
For me, September 11th is about the loss of innocents; it's about the first responders who rushed in to save lives; it's about my friends and neighbors who still suffer anxiety, respiratory illnesses, and other diseases from the fall-out; it's about the people of Chinatown who were largely ignored, even though they were the largest residential neighborhood adjacent to the attack site, even though their local economy was essentially shut down for months, because they're mainly immigrants and poorer people and many didn't speak English; it's about people on airplanes who must have known they were going to die but refused to let others become targets as well...
And it's about remembering that fear and hatred are what caused this tragedy in the first place. Lest we forget and become so consumed of fear and hatred that we become no better than the enemy our leaders claim to be fighting.

