
The shortlist for the Theakston Old Peculier Crime Novel of the Year 2026 has been announced. And I’ve read all of them! I’d already read 10 of the 18 books on the longlist, so it’s no great surprise. There are a couple of excellent books which I’d have included, but more of that later.
It’s a great list, and I’d happily recommend any of them. You’ve got dark and gritty american noir, psychological thriller, spies, spy-adjacent thriller, time-jumping murder mystery, something for everyone!
Let’s have a quick whiz through the list.
I flipping loved The Midnight King by Tariq Ashkanani.

A layered, complex exploration of a dark mind and the impact on family and community. One wise blogger (ok yes, it was me) said it was:
a book where all of the sentences just fit perfectly together, where nothing is wasted, nothing is quite as it appears on the surface, and which will leave you thinking about it for a long, long time.
Yes, I liked it. I liked it a lot.
The Death of Us by Abigail Dean is one which I’d heard so much about then finally picked up a copy (last one in the bookshop!) at Stockport Noir where I also had a brief chance to say hello and get it signed.

I’d heard a lot of good things about this book from a lot of people. They were not wrong. It’s a tough read and doesn’t hold back at all. It’s the story of Edward and Isabel, and how their world changed when a serial killer entered their home. The aftermath is just crushing. Beautifully written, this will live with you for a long, long time.
Beautiful Ugly by Alice Feeney was one I read back in January.

Absolute page turner, the story drew me in, and the writing and plot was great. Unfortunately the twist didn’t land for me but I know loads of others who absolutely loved it. I’ll definitely be picking up some more of Alice’s books though!
I really enjoyed The Frozen People by Elly Griffiths.

Ali Dawson works cold cases. So cold they’re frozen, she jokes. She works for a specialist unit who go back in time to solve crimes, and ends up in 1850 looking into a relative of wannabe PM Isaac Templeton. Except when she arrives in 1850 there’s a dead body at her feet, and she can’t seem to find her way back to the present day…
A cracking time-hop mystery! I really liked Ali Dawson, and loved the way she had to find her feet in 1850 – a modern woman dealing with a very unmodern society. Great plot and a fantastic start to a new series. Book 2 can’t come soon enough.
Clown Town by Mick Herron is the ninth in his fabulous Slough House series.

Whilst I love this series and adore Mick Herron’s turn of phrase (you’ll regularly find me cackling with laughter while reading) and utterly brilliant characters, I’m going to be a bit churlish here and ask whether the ninth book in a series by a hugely successful author is really one of the books of the year? Don’t get me wrong, it’s a great book and I’ll happily read and recommend Mick Herron to any and everyone!
I adored Quantum of Menace by Vaseem Khan.

Featuring everyone’s favourite Quartermaster, Quantum of Menace delves into what happens after Q is unceremoniously let go from MI6 and finds himself back in his small hometown of Wickstone-on-Water where his old friend Peter Napier turns up dead. Quantum computers, shady goings-on and a cameo from a certain super spy. I loved it. Very very much looking forward to the further adventures of Q!
So, what’s missing for me from the longlist? I’d love to have seen Alan Parks’ Gunner on there. I’m not usually a historical fiction kinda guy, but absolutely loved this one. Joseph Gunner is back from the war, discharged due to his (horrific) injuries on the front line in France, and now back in Glasgow. Fresh off the train he’s approached by his old boss Drummond, who wants him to look into something odd involving a body that turned up after a bombing raid. What exactly is a mutilated German doing there? Conspiracies abound. Joe Gunner is a brilliant character and I absolutely cannot wait to find out what happens next.
I also really enjoyed Sarah Pinborough’s We Live Here Now, which was delightfully creepy and weird and interesting, as all of Sarah’s books are!
Have you read any on the shortlist? Any catch your eye? Who will you be voting for? It’s a tricky choice!

























