In his biography of Hitchcock, The Dark Side of Genius, Donald Spoto writes
that Hitchcock’s book-long series of interviews with François Truffaut “hurt and
disappointed just about everybody who had ever worked wi... more abstract
In his biography of Hitchcock, The Dark Side of Genius, Donald Spoto writes
that Hitchcock’s book-long series of interviews with François Truffaut “hurt and
disappointed just about everybody who had ever worked with Alfred Hitchcock, for
the interviews reduced the writers, the designers, the photographers, the composers,
and the actors to little else than elves in the master carpenter’s workshop” (495).
Naturally, these interviews took an auteurist perspective because Truffaut, as a
director himself, was one of its early exponents. However, diminishing the
participation of other contributors in the creative and artistic process in favour of the
director is still a very contentious issue for film scholars. In this paper I intend to
interrogate the traditional idea of “auteurism” in relation to Van Sant’s role as director
of the “Death Trilogy” and Paranoid Park, and posit instead the idea of “collective
auteurism” involving Van Sant and his sound designer for the four films, Leslie
Shatz. This collaboration produced a distinct audio-visual landscape that has
become one of the defining characteristics of the four films.
Other scholars still argue for Van Sant as the sole “auteur”. In his book Gus
Van Sant: His Own Private Cinema, LoBrutto argues this position and attributes the
soundscapes of Van Sant’s films to him alone. He writes: “Van Sant, like David
Lynch and all good total filmmakers, is a master of sound design” (18). However, the
“Death Quartet” is a very much a collective project; both Van Sant and Leslie Shatz
incorporate the ideas of others (including actors, cinematographers, and musicians)
while allowing the films to be open-ended in their meanings. Throughout the four
films Shatz worked within the template laid out by Van Sant’s concept of the “Death
Quartet”, and Van Sant’s creative aspirations had a subsequent impact on Shatz’s
sound-design choices. Spontaneity, communication and trust all play their parts in
the creative process, and I argue that this dynamic between the two men is crucial to
the concept of “collective auteurism”. My paper argues for an approach to Van Sant’s
“Death Quartet” that recognizes the director’s influence on the soundtrack of this
particular project without writing
sound designer Leslie Shatz.